Hey everyone! Today Vera and I are here to do the Would You Rather tag! We were tagged by the lovely Meeghan @ MeeghanReads – thank you! – and let me tell you: these questions were hard! Even so, we managed to answer them all, though I may have lost a little part of my soul in doing so.
Would you rather only read physical books for the rest of your life or only audiobooks?
Sabrina: This is an easy answer for me – the only truly easy answer of this whole tag. I would much rather only read physical books for the rest of my life. I’ve tried audiobooks only a few times and though they are sometimes good, they are not convenient for me.
Vera: This is so hard! I’ve recently fallen in love with audiobooks and they are so darn convenient for me. That said, I do love physical books and I’m not sure I could live without them. Hm.. right now I’m going to have to go with audiobooks, especially if I can still read ebooks. After all, those are not physical books, right?
Would you rather know all the spoilers before you start a book or never read the last chapter?
Sabrina: I think I’m going to go with never reading the last chapter! Sure, sometimes it would be a huge problem because I’d miss important details, but if I’m honest with you… sometimes the last chapter makes me feel impatient. A lot of the times it just wraps things up or gives you a glimpse into the future happiness of the characters. If I knew all the spoilers, I would never be surprised by a book and I think that would be worse for me.
Vera: I hate spoilers, I do, but the last chapter tends to be more than just an epilogue – which I could technically live without – so I’ll have to go with knowing all the spoilers. I’ve always thought that truly good books wouldn’t be ruined were they spoiled, so let us hope that’s true in this hypothetical situation.
Would you rather be stuck on a very long train/plane ride with a book you hate or no book at all?
Sabrina: I would rather be stuck with a book I hate! Depending on why I hate it, I still might find it entertaining to read, and even if I don’t at least I still would have the choice to read it or not.
Vera: I think these two are, arguably, the same, right? If I hate a book, I’ll likely not read it anyway, in which case I’d rather have no book with me at all. I’m more than okay with listening to music, or to a podcast.
Would you rather read a book with a really bad ending or a book where your favourite character is killed off?
Sabrina: The joke is on this question, because I read books where my favourite character is killed off all the time 🙃 Honestly though, a bad ending can really ruin a whole book for me, whereas my favourite character being killed off is more likely to make me sad than angry – so that’s what I’m going with.
Vera: I’m going to go with my favorite character being killed off. I wouldn’t like that, obviously, but I’d rather have that than a bad ending that can potentially ruin the whole book/series for me.
Would you rather love a book everyone hates or hate a book everyone loves?
Sabrina: I would always rather love a book than hate one (…this doesn’t contradict my answer to the long ride question, does it? 😅)
Vera: Hating a book everyone loves suuucks. It happens to me a few times each year, and I’m unsure who to rant about the book in this case. I’d rather love a book everyone hates, because in that case I can try to push it onto my friends and hope that they’ll like it. I cannot, however, push people to read a book I hated just because I want to rant about it.
Would you rather read books by your favourite author but they’re all really bad, or read books by an author you hate but they’re all really good?
Sabrina: My answer is the same as Vera’s! 👇
Vera: The second one, as long as I hate the author because their previous works have disappointed me. I like to be surprised, and this would be a particularly nice surprise! But if I hate the author because they’re bigoted in any way.. I’d rather not read or enjoy their novels.
Would you rather only ever read contemporary books for the rest of your life or fantasy?
Sabrina: If you’d asked me this last year, I would have answered fantasy without a second thought but… most of my 5-star reads this year have been contemporary, so I’m having a bit of a crisis. Even so, I’m still going to choose fantasy because there is so much variety among them and I’d be guaranteed never to get bored.
Vera: I read loads of contemporary and romance novels this year.. and yet, I cannot give up on fantasy novels. They’re so magical and complex, and they can have most of the elements contemporary novels do. They can have romance, friendship, family, real life problems.. everything, while contemporary can’t replicate the worlds, magic systems etc. that fantasy has to offer.
Would you rather own a signed edition or a first edition?
Sabrina: I have to go with a signed edition! There is just something magical about knowing that the exact book you are holding in your hands has also been held by the very author who wrote it.
Vera: I’ve never been super-hyped about signed editions, but first editions – especially of some of my favorite classics – would be really cool to own. On a side note, this question brought out my mercenary side, which is seeing dollar signs next to valuable first edition copies. 🤑
Would you rather never be able to borrow a book from the library again or never reread your favourite book?
Sabrina: The only way I can read the amount of books that I do is by having access to an incredible library system. I just couldn’t afford it otherwise. While I do love rereading – and I reread my favourite book every year – I would have to give that up in this distressing hypothetical situation 😭 😭 😭
Vera: I love rereading, so I’ll have to go with never borrowing from the library again. This decision is helped by the fact that our libraries are not what I’d call well-stocked and they don’t really have any English novels.
Would you rather spend the day in your favourite fictional world but never meet your favourite character, or spend the day as the villain and try to attack/kill that favourite character?
Sabrina: Meeting my favourite character would make me so nervous, so it is with only a little bit of disappointment that I say I would simply spend the day in their fictional world without coming across them. Besides that, I would never want to try and attack or kill them!!
Vera: My favorites are either (1) incredibly soft babies who I could never harm, or (2) tough as hell who would kill me with no remorse. So the only viable option is spending a day in my favorite fictional world. Honestly, I wouldn’t even mind not meeting my favorites, because how much can you chat with someone in a day? Not a lot, especially if you’re as awkward as I am.
What do you think?
What do you think of our choices? Would you rather know all the spoilers before you start a book or never read the last chapter? Let us know!
16 thoughts on “Tough Choices With The Would You Rather Tag”
So many great but hard questions! 🙈 I don’t mind spoilers so I think I would rather know all the spoilers rather than not reading the final chapter, and yeah, I totally agree with you about choosing to kill my favorite character rather than having bad ending- in fact I think most of my favorite books have that tragic ending 🙃
Such hard choices..!
I love this tag! I’m with Sabrina on the first one, I’d be happy to only read physical books for the rest of my life. I do love my Kindle though, but if I’d have the oppotunity to buy all the books in the world… 😀
I really only like audiobooks when I am reading a non-fiction book and the narrator is the author. I feel like they can tell their own story really well. I have tried audiobooks for fiction books but I always end up falling asleep haha. I just can’t get into them unfortunately.
I also would have to agree with you Sabrina that the library is where I get access to most of my books. Without it, I wouldn’t read nearly as much as I do! Unfortunately I will never be able to reread Station Eleven (my favourite book) again, but that is a chance I am willing to take.
I love this tag and your guys’ answers. Funnily, I would choose the opposite of your picks for many of these questions. The spoilers questions especially haha! I want to know all of the spoilers and I also read the ending of a book first.
You weren’t lying about these being tough choices.
this was such a fun post and I really liked both of your answers!!! these questions WERE really hard. i laughed at the spoilers question because i’ve accidentally spoiled books/movies for myself so many times so really i’ve faced this question in real life. i do have to say that it’s never really ruined the journey for me, though!! but also yes to the main character being killed off, i agree with Sabrina I love to read books where my favorite character is killed off. and YES to the hating a book everyone loves being so horrible. there’s a book i HATED which absolutely everybody on book blogs seems to love — and i just don’t know who to talk to about it??? but i do enjoy hearing people’s rants on books i liked. my sister, for instance, DESPISES six of crows, calls it the worst book she’s ever read and personally i think its so funny to hear her talk about it. and i definitely agree with you guys on fantasy having so much variety! they have so much to it. liked this post a ton ❤
These really are some tough choices! Although, the first one is easy for me. I would definitely choose physical books. I also only have read I think one fantasy in my life? So the choice between fantasy and contemporary is already made i guess 😂
I really loved reading this post! 🙂
This is a wonderful tag and your choices made sense! Signed editions vs first editions — aargh that is HARD. For the question : Would you rather know all the spoilers before you start a book or never read the last chapter? I would probably never read the last chapter, because if I knew all the spoilers before starting a book, I don’t think I’d see the point in reading it. And for the question : Would you rather spend the day in your favourite fictional world but never meet your favourite character, or spend the day as the villain and try to attack/kill that favourite character? I would also go with the former, because you might be walking where the character walked…lol! Also, I’m a fan of world and worldbuilding so yeah!
Oh, these were so many hard choices and I liked reading what you would do! 😊 If I had to choose, I would probably go with reading Fantasy for the rest of my life as it’s my ultimate favorite genre 🥰 And I honestly couldn’t decide if I would want to be spoiled or never read the last chapter 😱
oh the audiobook one is hard! While sometimes the narrators are terrible, I would get a lot more reading in (especially now with a kid). So then the question is quality or quantity? lol
I really love this tag though! I think I’m going to give it a try! So thanks for showing me it 🙂
These are great questions and SO HARD! Though I would totally rather read the book I hate than no book- at least I can snark and hate-read hahah. Some of these I really cannot decide, both choices are too hard! Like spoilers are bad, but no last chapter!? HOW?! Totally agree with you both about the author question, that is exactly how I’d have answered too!
Ahhh, some of these are so hard! I go back and forth on the spoilers vs. last chapter one. I think I would rather know the spoilers? Because I could still enjoy the journey of the story even if I know where it’s headed, but I don’t think I’d be able to live with reading a book for so long only to not finish it. But ugh, that’s difficult! I loved reading your reasoning for each choice; you swayed me on a few of them because of your logic!
Ah this is such a great post, SO many of these questions are SO hard to answer! Honestly I really hesitated about the one where you’re stuck on a long ride with a book you hate or no book at all. I think in the end I’d pick no book at all, because the book I hate would frustrate me even more hahahaha. I guess the easiest to answer for me would be the first one, physical books all the way 😀
Loved this!! 🙂